Throughout the ages, Jewish theologians have tried to make sense of why
a benevolent God allows human suffering. To account for human evil, we can say
that God gave us free will, but how do we explain suffering that is part of
nature? Hundreds of years ago in the north of Israel, Rabbi Luria described
a creation story startlingly like the "Big Bang." When God's light
was too powerful to be contained in the vessels of the universe, creation was
shattered, flawed from the start. But the scattered shards of divine light are
everywhere, in every situation, waiting to be gathered up and repaired in a
process that he called Tikkun Olam, a process that has become a modern Jewish
synonym for Social Action. Centuries later Rabbi Harold Kushner's classic book,
"When Bad Things Happen to Good People" would provide a more modern
and rationalist version of the same idea: God is good and loving, but not all-controlling.
God needs us to serve as partners in healing, repairing and perfecting God's
still-incomplete creation.
Another explanation of why nature is not always kind comes from the two main
names for the Divine in Jewish tradition: Elohim (God) and Adonai (Lord or Eternal).
Throughout the Bible, these two names for God that recur again and again: Elohim
and Adonai.
Tradition equates Elohim with God's attributes of judgment and Adonai with
God's attributes of mercy. Rabbi Harold Schulweis is the most recent teacher
to emphasize this traditional Jewish explanation of our two experiences of God.
In the opening chapter of the Torah, creation is described as the work of Elohim.
Hassidic thinkers pointed out that the name Elohim is equal in gematria, Hebrew
numerology, to "Hateva," meaning "Nature." When we say "nature,"
we really mean God's creation, which is filled with God's Presence. So how is
that equivalent to "judgment?" Nature is beautiful and uplifting.
Many if not most of us find God, experience the Shechinah or Divine Presence,
when we commune with nature. But nature can also be awesomely destructive. Nature
has its laws, laws which are fundamental to our existence. Laws like gravity
or chemical reactions are morally neutral. As the Talmud points out on several
occasions, regardless of our moral intentions, "Olam k'darko noheg"-the
world follows its natural course. Nature has its own processes that are based
on natural laws set in motion with the process of creation.
At the same time, Judaism has another name for God, "Adonai," translated
"Lord," or "Eternal."
Actually, Adonai is the substitute name that we use for God's four letter
sacred name, the Yud-Hey-Vav-Hey, which we no longer pronounce out of reverence
for its sanctity. Adonai represents the transcendent aspect of God. Our lives
are not limited by the laws of nature. We always have the possibility of transformation,
of transcendence, of mercy and kindness, represented in the name Adonai. Adonai
inspires the overflowing of love, courage, caring, and goodness that often follows
the worst disasters.
When human beings are created, the names of Adonai and Elohim are joined together
as Adonai Elohim, the Lord God. Likewise in the Shema and in our blessings we
join the two names and aspects of God by saying, "Adonai Eloheynu,"
"the Lord is our God."
In Unetaneh Tokef, a central prayer of the High Holidays, which we will recite
at Musaf tomorrow, we catalog the list of natural disasters that may overtake
human beings in the year ahead: "who by fire and who by water," and
so forth. These represent the aspect of Elohim, the aspect of reality that is
beyond our control. But we conclude with the phrase, "But Teshuvah, Tefillah
and Tzedakah-repentance, prayer and righteousness, overcome the evil of the
decree." This doesn't mean that we can change nature through these means,
but that through changing our behavior we can bring healing and transformation
into almost any situation.
For now we must turn to human responsibility. While natural disasters originate
in nature, they are also inextricably linked to human society. They are not
just "acts of nature," but nature inter-acting with human society.
We saw this in stark relief during Hurricane Katrina. Poverty, inequality, government
priorities, population growth in vulnerable areas, and many other factors make
"acts of God" much worse for human beings. If you think that natural
disasters are getting worse in recent years, you are right, according to a United
Nations website on the environment. But it's not simply that there are more
such events, but that there are more people living in the most vulnerable areas,
and particularly people who are poor, lack insurance, or live in flimsy housing
that is easily destroyed.
In addition, we human beings are drastically degrading the environment by cutting
down forests and destroying wetlands that protect from flooding, and releasing
carbon dioxide that leads to global warming and climate change, making weather
disasters more severe. Dramatic one-time events grab the headlines, but probably
the greater environmental threat to our planetary future comes from slow changes
like deforestation, melting polar ice-caps, destruction of species and depletion
of natural resources, the ongoing ravages of wars and conflicts, or the spread
of diseases such as AIDS that are devastating whole populations in Africa. These
disastrous slow natural disasters are acts of humanity.
Our prayerbook, from the Reconstructionist movement, once took out the traditional
second paragraph of the Shema, which they understood to describe drought and
exile from the land as mechanistic punishments from God. But with our more modern
understanding of the environment, we know that failing to live in harmony with
the laws of Elohim, the laws of nature, will indeed lead to environmental degradation
and disaster. So the editors of our prayerback acknowledged the wisdom of our
sources and put back the second paragraph of the Shema.
Some people in our congregation have lived through natural disasters or witnessed
the aftermath firsthand. A few years ago, my family and I were stranded for
three days while on vacation in the Texas hill country when a massive flood
took place. What I saw then is that natural disasters can bring out the worst
in some people, but surprisingly they can bring out the best in far more people.
They bring out the quality inspired by Adonai, the transcendent power of compassion
and caring. Thus we have seen that in recent disasters, there has been an outpouring
of tzedakah, or charity and good deeds to help others. What the Torah, what
the prophets would tell us is: don't wait for a dramatic event to do these mitzvoth.
According to the prophet Isaiah, social justice and charity provide the true
meaning of our Yom Kippur fast. That's why we have provided materials and envelopes
to enable us to donate to two outstanding national Jewish tzedakah organizations:
Mazon provides food for the hungry (including victims of the hurricanes) and
American Jewish World Service does world-class work in alleviating poverty and
injustice throughout the planet. Don't leave them on the table. Tomorrow afternoon
at 3:00 we will have a Social Action forum to learn and share ways that we can
contribute to Tikkun Olam, healing the world. Instead of staying home and watching
the clock, join us. Fasting and praying isn't enough. We have to give tzedakah
and we should each find an action to take to heal and repair the world.
If human beings could practice empathy, compassion, and giving to others on
a daily basis, if we could reach out to conquer poverty, mend society, heal
the environment and stop the "slow natural disasters" that are going
on behind the headlines every day, then we would truly reach "heavenly
days right here on earth," the coming of the Messianic era. May this Yom
Kippur be the day that we each resolve to find and do our part for Tikkun Olam.
May we interact with nature for the good, and may we act in God's image, as
God's partners, as God's hands bringing healing and transformation to society
and to our planet. Amen.